Olympic rower in privacy war with Henley neighbour over garden gym (2025)

A former Olympic rower is embroiled in a row with her neighbours over their plans to build a gym studio she fears will ruin her privacy.

Games silver medalist Miriam Luke MBE, 60, is among objectors in picturesque Henley-on-Thames, Oxfordshire, railing against the proposal.

One of her neighboursLucy Marsh wants to builda single-storey side extension in their back garden.

But the retired rower fears the plans, which want to replace an existing garage and shed with a 'contemporary' building, will negatively impact her.

The designs include an entrance hall and snug/study, an open-plan living and kitchen area, alongside a utility and shower room.

This will also be accompanied by a four metre by seven metre 'garden room' which is specifically designed to 'allow space for a studio/gym with showering facilities'.

The planning application, submitted on March 3, is currently being considered by her local council, who MailOnline with a target decision date of April 30.

A design and access statement given by Simon March Architecture declares that 'careful consideration has been given to ensuring that the adjacent bungalows are not affected by the extension and that their right to life is respected.'

Three-time Olympic rower Miriam Luke nee Batten MBE, 60 (pictured right), is stuck in a row with her neighbours in Henley-on-Thames who have plans to construct a single-storey side extension in their back garden

Ms Luke won a silver medal at the 2000 Olympic games in Sydney, Australia, competing in the quadruple scull with her younger sister, Guin

Ms Luke (pictured) has said she is 'concerned about the size and location' of the proposed extension, citing fears for its close proximity to the neighbouring fence and significant noise

It adds: 'The proposed garden room is to be offset from the boundary by 1.3m minimum, possibly timber cladding and to have a flat roof to minimise visual impact.'

However, nearby resident Ms Luke said she was 'concerned about the size and location' of the extension, citing fears for its close proximity to the neighbouring fence, significant noise and even the likelihood of it becoming a rental let.

Ms Luke said: 'There are currently two very tall trees, a diseased, ivy clad, horse chestnut and an evergreen. What will happen to the two trees when the studio/gym is built?

'Currently we enjoy the privacy they create for our gardens and house however they are also very tall and obscure sunshine from our solar panels for a few hours in the morning.'

Ms Luke won a silver medal at the 2000 games inSydney, Australia, competing in the quadruple scull with her younger sister, Guin.

The crew successfully brought home Britain's first ever women's Olympic rowing medal, with the renowned athlete then going on to chair the Henley Women's Regatta from 2012 to 2021, alongside serving as the Village Manager for Rowing and Canoe Sprint for the London 2012 Olympic Games.

After 40 years of dedication to the sport, Ms Luke was then even awarded an MBE in the 2024 New Year's Honours List for her services to women's rowing.

Now, she is amongst several other neighbours who have objected to the proposed building, with another nearby resident saying that they believed the height of the proposed garden studio would be 'too close' to their garden, and would therefore cause noise problems.

Plans for the contentious garden extension, in replacement of an existing garage and shed, include a 'contemporary' building comprising of an entrance hall and snug/study, an open-plan living and kitchen area, alongside a utility and shower room

Pictured: the garage set to be demolished by neighbours in replacement of a garden gym

The planning application, submitted on March 3, is currently being considered by South Oxfordshire District Council, with a target decision date of April 30

Ms Luke was part of the crew that brought home Britain's first ever women's Olympic rowing medal

Ms Samantha Petrie said: 'The garden room is too close to our boundary. The garden room listed as a gym/studio, together with the proposed shower room, raises concerns that it will be used as an Airbnb-type rental or used for classes by the public, thereby affecting amenity of the garden through noise.'

The Henley Society, a local civic society group that seek to 'enhance Henley's rich heritage', even remarked that they fear the proposal could 'double the size of the property'.

They added: 'There is potential for serious light pollution and more details are required and so we recommend refusal for the time being.'

The proposed development proved divisive in a planning meeting on Tuesday, April 8, with both the Mayor Rory Hunt and Councillor Michelle Thomas being outspoken against the development's impact on neighbouring trees and possibility for noise pollution.

Councillor Hunt said: 'I think it's overdevelopment and the impact on the trees is significant. The potential for light pollution is fairly high'.

After 40 years in the sport, Ms Luke (pictured left, alongside Gillian Lindsay), was even awarded an MBE in the 2024 New Year's Honours List for her services to women's rowing

Submitting an objection to the application, Ms Luke said: 'There are currently two very tall trees, a diseased, ivy clad, horse chestnut and an evergreen. What will happen to the two trees when the studio/gym is built?

Pictured: the 'two very tall trees' in Ms Luke's garden that she fears could be removed if the proposed construction goes ahead

Read MoreEXCLUSIVE My neighbour wants to build a monstrous extension... I won't feel safe in my own home

Councillor Thomas also raised concerns about the development being 'very near' to neighbours' boundaries, citing their fears that 'the studio is going to be of harm'.

Councillor Thomas added: 'The studio sits very high because of its position so it will be very visible for those people who want to enjoy their garden.

'We should say it needs to be ancillary to the main dwelling because I think they mentioned it could be turned into some kind of Airbnb.'

However, Deputy Mayor Tom Buckley said he did not believe the plans could cause a 'significant harm' or impact on neighbouring properties, while Councillor Laurence Plant recommended mitigation as a method to help resolve the neighbour dispute surrounding the removal of the plants.

As a result, subject to the introduction of a replacement planting scheme, the committee recommended the approval of the building.

The council, who MailOnline has decided not to name due to Ms Luke's privacy concerns, declined to comment given that the planning application 'is currently under consideration'.

Ms Luke and Ms Marsh were both approached for comment.

Olympic rower in privacy war with Henley neighbour over garden gym (2025)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Manual Maggio

Last Updated:

Views: 5697

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Manual Maggio

Birthday: 1998-01-20

Address: 359 Kelvin Stream, Lake Eldonview, MT 33517-1242

Phone: +577037762465

Job: Product Hospitality Supervisor

Hobby: Gardening, Web surfing, Video gaming, Amateur radio, Flag Football, Reading, Table tennis

Introduction: My name is Manual Maggio, I am a thankful, tender, adventurous, delightful, fantastic, proud, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.